It was widely reported that the protocol would allow countries to
ban the import of a genetically modified crops and foods and to enforce
labeling of such foods. The official line is that the protocol puts trade
and the environment on equal footing and many environmental groups have
thus given favourable a reaction
In reality however, a clause added at the end of the negotiations ensures
that the new protocol does not override other international agreements,
including World Trade Organisation free trade rules. Under WTO rules imports
of GMO's cannot be banned. The WTO has ruled that the European Union's
ban on the import of GE hormone treated beef is illegal. The addition
of the clause was a victory for the governments of the US and the other
major agricultural exporters, Argentina, Australia, Canada, Chile and
Uruguay, known as the Miami Group, who want to be free to export GE foods.
The Miami Group also persuaded the signatories to put off for at least
two years from the pact's implementation proposals to track and regulate
global shipments of GE foodstuffs
SOURCES
"Critics Fear New Treaty Subordinates Biosafety to
Trade" Danielle Knight, Inter Press Service, Feb 1st, 2000
http://www.igc.org/trac/headlines/2000/29.html
UKabc, Cartagena Protocol page
http://ds.dial.pipex.com/ukfg/UKabc/cartagena.htm
'
|